History of Christmas in America: ‘The Battle for Christmas’

by | Nov 24, 2007

The Battle for Christmas, by Stephen Nissenbaum

Now that Thanksgiving is in the rearview mirror, we can look forward to a full month of Christmas ads in the newspapers, Christmas commercials and specials on TV, Christmas music on the radio and in every retail store, and Christmas decorations throughout our neighborhoods. In view of this, I thought it might be a perfect time to recommend an excellent book on the holiday, The Battle for Christmas, by Stephen Nissenbaum, published in 1996.

This book is a history of Christmas in America, and has nothing to do with the “war on Christmas” conjured by rabble-rousing demagogues like Bill O’Reilly, nor does it say much about December 25th being ripped off from Sol Invictus or Saturnalia or the birthdays of Ishtar or Mithra. However, the fact that this holiday was originally not a Christian festival is noted.

Why Christmas is commercial

The Battle for Christmas tells how a once boisterous orgy was deliberately tamed in the United States into the tradition of family Christmas shopping and commercialism that we know today. The Christmas holiday was transformed by a small club of wealthy men in New York, members of an elite, politically conservative set opposed to democracy and known as the Knickerbockers. These patricians included author Washington Irving as well as Clement Clarke Moore, credited with writing A Visit from St. Nicholas (a.k.a. Twas the Night Before Christmas).

Christmas was historically rowdy

Initially, Nissenbaum explains, Christmas for many early Americans was a season of “misrule” — an extended post-harvest festival of drunkenness, rowdiness, and lust carried over from similar traditions in England and Europe in general. It was a time of relaxation and plenty, and also a time of release, during which the hostility of the commoners toward their rich bosses was vented. This, as Nissenbaum unravels, was the original sense of “wassailing,” which incorporated the very real, physical threat of tipsy peasants plundering their rich overlords. He also delves into the way this annual disorder played out in the southern United States, with slaves being temporarily permitted to drink, and slave owners taking sexual advantage of slave women.

Meanwhile, for the most religious early Americans, Christmas was an embarrassing non-event. The view of the Puritans was that December 25th had no connection at all to the birth of Jesus Christ, and was merely a varnished-over pagan festival. Puritans deliberately ignored Christmas, went about their business as normally as possible, and held no celebrations. They even purged Christmas from their almanacs, and passed laws to fine anyone found observing Christmas.

All of this emotional froth came to a head in New York City (previously New Amsterdam), where the threatened capitalists finally took Christmas into their own hands. Borrowing the figure of Sinterklaas from the Dutch, they fashioned a new American stay-at-home tradition revolving around family members buying gifts for each other.

A show of the rich feeding the poor

So delighted were these Knickerbockers by this new spirit of giving that they staged a Christmas event at Madison Square Garden in which they arrived in top hats and furs to sit in the good seats and watch orphan newsboys chow down on a free, raucous feast. This story alone is worth reading the book for, and it echoes even today in local TV news reports from our urban homeless shelters.

Nissenbaum also traces the evolution of Santa Claus from a working class hero into a sugar daddy, he finds the original Christmas tree in Germany, and he connects the Christmas dots to Purim, the blues, and Kwanzaa. He does a fantastic job of untangling a truly confusing set of beliefs and traditions and smoothing it all against the tapestry of American history.

It’s usually easier to reconcile yourself to something once you understand its background and development. In that regard, this book on the history of Christmas is a remedial revelation.

I am not kidding in the least when I say that The Battle for Christmas has helped me endure “the most wonderful time of the year.”

1 Comment

  1. Louis Mendizabal

    The Puritans banned that stupid holiday and Spurgeon wrote about it No one knows Gods birthday and if you did birthdays are pagan,,,, and deaths are recorded in scripture with birthday celebration!……..Everyday is a Day in Christ….Christmas has nothing to do with; anything about anything, but Matt. 1:21


Have anything to add?

My latest

Another Week: Number 40

Late afternoon waterskiing on Brown's Lake in Burlington, Wisconsin, Friday, September 29, 2023 Rabbit, rabbit. We continue to ride the fluctuations. Amy's appetite for solid food has waned. Vomiting lurks after any small bite....

Another Week: Number 39

Sign pointing to Radiation Oncology in Specialty Clinics Building at Froedtert Hospital, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. Logistically speaking, our pace through the cancer Habitrail has become more hurried. Amy is on several tracks at...

Another Week: Number 38

Amy Czerniec in neuro-opthalmologist's examination room, Froedtert Hospital Vision Services, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, September 15, 2023. We continue to scurry through our cancer Habitrail — up and down the interstate, parking...

Another Week: Number 37

First day of school at Mitchell School, Racine, Wisconsin, September 5, 2023. I always imagine this week as the beginning of a long chute to the new year. Summer is a thirteen-week plateau, floating lazily on peaceful waters —...

Another Week: Number 36

Cups for clean pens and used pens at Froedtert Neuroscience Clinic check-in, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. Seven more days are in the books as Amy and her doctors strategize against cancer. She made three more trips up to Froedtert in...

Another Week: Number 35

Kenosha Transit electric streetcar along 54th St. at 2nd Ave. on August 22, 2023. Neither of us has been getting enough exercise this summer, but I particularly wanted Amy to get some steps in, so we did a slow mile at Sanders...

Another Week: Number 34

Murky AI “art” displayed in the Level 4 corridor of Froedtert Clinical Cancer Center, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. More headaches and nausea for Amy, and another indictment for former president Donald Trump (just looking at those four...

Another Week: Number 33

Sugar maple tree turning colors at Mitchell School in Racine, Wisconsin, August 11, 2023. We have arrived at the end of summer. The sugar maple at the northwest corner of Mitchell School which indicates this to me annually has...

Another Week: Number 32

Amy Czerniec on Tuesday, August 1st, awaiting release from her 8CFAC room at Froedtert Hospital, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. It's amazing how things can sometimes turn around when several teams of first-rate professionals use the...

Another Week: Number 31

Whiteboard welcome message at 8CFAC, Froedtert Hospital, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. We were caged this week — Amy in her cold hospital room, pinned to her pillow by pain in her cranium, and me commuting between there and our...